Used BMW 535I for Sale in Indianapolis, IN

8 listingsPriced from $6,988 to $18,998Median $11,750

As of September 2026, VehiSales tracks 8 Used BMW 535I for sale in Indianapolis, IN, with asking prices between $6,988 and $18,998 (median $11,750). The most listed model is BMW 535I. Every listing includes photos, mileage, dealer details and a vehicle history check on VehiSales.

The inventory leans toward sedans (8). Model years span 2010–2016.

Newest First
No location set
Showing 8 of 8 vehicles
2015 BMW 535I xDrive
Used

2015 BMW 535i

xDrive

$18,998
68k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Indianapolis, IN
VINWBA5B3C55FD539933
Used
Great price

2015 BMW 535i

xDrive

$9,828
136k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Muncie, IN
VINWBA5B3C58FD545256
Used

2010 BMW 535i

535i

$6,988
154k mi
Gas
6a
20 MPG
Frankfort, IN
VINWBANW1C56AC168174
Used

2014 BMW 535i

xDrive

$11,644
109k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Greenwood, IN
VINWBA5B3C51ED293249
Used

2014 BMW 535i

Sedan

$12,745
61k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Indianapolis, IN
VINWBA5B1C52ED478592
Used

2016 BMW 535i

xDrive

$11,750
100k mi
Gasoline
8-Sp.
23 MPG
Indianapolis, IN
VINWBA5B3C5XGG257724
Used

2013 BMW 535i

Sedan

$11,995
77k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
24 MPG
Indianapolis, IN
VINWBAFR7C57DC827754
Used

2016 BMW 535i

Sedan

Call for Price
85k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Crawfordsville, IN
VINWBA5B1C53GG553690