Used BMW 535I for Sale in Indianapolis, IN

13 listingsPriced from $6,988 to $14,995Median $12,199

As of October 2026, VehiSales tracks 13 Used BMW 535I for sale in Indianapolis, IN, with asking prices between $6,988 and $14,995 (median $12,199). The most listed model is BMW 535I. Every listing includes photos, mileage, dealer details and a vehicle history check on VehiSales.

The inventory leans toward sedans (13). Model years span 2010–2016.

Newest First
Make: Bmw
Model: 535i
No location set
Showing 13 of 13 vehicles
2015 BMW 535I xDrive
Used

2015 BMW 535i

xDrive

$12,199
95k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Fishers, IN
VINWBA5B3C5XFD540785
Used

2014 BMW 535i

xDrive

$14,995
66k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Indianapolis, IN
VINWBA5B3C58ED533333
Used

2014 BMW 535i

xDrive

$11,224
122k mi
Gasoline
8-Sp.
23 MPG
Anderson, IN
VINWBA5B3C52ED531447
Used

2012 BMW 535i

xDrive

$12,888
70k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Indianapolis, IN
VINWBAFU7C50CDU58940
Used

2014 BMW 535i

xDrive

$14,300
63k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Indianapolis, IN
VINWBA5B3C50ED292352
Used

2010 BMW 535i

535i

$6,988
154k mi
Gas
6a
20 MPG
Frankfort, IN
VINWBANW1C56AC168174
Used

2014 BMW 535i

xDrive

$14,990
71k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Fisher, IN
VINWBA5B3C58ED533283
Used

2012 BMW 535i

Sedan

$10,488
84k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Indianapolis, IN
VINWBAFR7C59CC814521
Used

2014 BMW 535i

Sedan

$10,261
134k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Indianapolis, IN
VINWBA5B1C59ED475267
Used

2011 BMW 535i

xDrive

$10,840
115k mi
Gas
8a
23 MPG
Indianapolis, IN
VINWBAFU7C59BC873548
Used

2013 BMW 535i

xDrive

Call for Price
127k mi
Gasoline
8-Sp.
24 MPG
Frankfort, IN
VINWBAFU7C55DDU77260
Used

2016 BMW 535i

Sedan

Call for Price
85k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Crawfordsville, IN
VINWBA5B1C53GG553690
Used

2016 BMW 535i

Sedan

$14,237
90k mi
Gasoline
Auto.
23 MPG
Greenwood, IN
VINWBA5B1C57GG134533