Used BMW M440I Prices by Year

As of November 2026, a used BMW M440I typically lists for $51,332 in the US. Depending on model year, typical asking prices run from $37,120 for a 2021 to $61,647 for a 2026 — every figure below is a national median of 738 live listings, not a book value, and the M440I steps down a median 9.8% per model year of age.

$51,332Typical used M440I asking price
$37,120–$61,647Typical price span, 2021 → 2026
738Live listings behind these numbers

BMW M440I price by model year

YearTypical priceMost listings fall betweenAvg mileageEPA combinedNCAPFor sale
2026 $61,647 $54,502 – $71,512 9,582 mi 27–30 MPG — 158
2025 $57,376 $51,278 – $68,268 16,490 mi 27–30 MPG — 70
2024 $51,332 $44,847 – $58,016 28,755 mi 25–27 MPG — 186
2023 $46,317 $39,900 – $54,995 34,911 mi 25–27 MPG — 111
2022 $42,998 $36,500 – $48,954 45,155 mi 25–28 MPG — 121
2021 $37,120 $29,541 – $45,531 54,596 mi 25–26 MPG — 92

“Typical price” is the national median asking price; the range covers the middle 80% of listings (10th–90th percentile), so it excludes teaser and outlier prices on both ends.

Cheapest BMW M440I

The cheapest quotable model year is the 2021, typically listing for $37,120 (most between $29,541 and $45,531) with an average odometer of 54,596 miles. Among recent model years, the least-expensive common trim is the GRAN COUPE at a typical $52,810. Before chasing the lowest price, weigh mileage against a one-year-newer car — each model year of age saves a median 9.8%, and the per-year table above shows where the price-per-mile balance is best. See the cheapest BMW M440I listings for sale →

Most expensive BMW M440I

The priciest used model year is the 2026 at a typical $61,647 (most between $54,502 and $71,512). The most expensive common trim is the CONVERTIBLE, typically $57,611 — a $4,801 spread over the base GRAN COUPE within the same nameplate.

BMW M440I price by trim (last 4 model years)

The trim changes the price more than a model year does: the cheapest common trim, the GRAN COUPE, typically lists for $52,810; the priciest, the CONVERTIBLE, for $57,611. The XDRIVE is what the used market mostly stocks — 42.9% of trim-labeled listings, while the CONVERTIBLE is the rarest quotable trim at 6.3%.

TrimTypical priceMost listings fall betweenShare of listingsAvg mileage
XDRIVEMost popular $56,170 $45,995 – $69,654 42.9% 20,211 mi
XDRIVE GC $53,292 $44,700 – $62,449 28.7% 25,281 mi
GRAN COUPECheapest $52,810 $44,914 – $60,584 11.2% 22,907 mi
M440I COUPE $52,991 $45,355 – $62,500 11.0% 19,100 mi
CONVERTIBLEPriciest $57,611 $49,311 – $61,689 6.3% 21,119 mi

Share = portion of the model's trim-labeled used listings from the last 4 model years — a supply-side popularity signal. Trims with fewer than 25 live cars are not quoted.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a used BMW M440I cost?

As of November 2026, a used BMW M440I typically lists for $51,332 nationally. Depending on model year, typical prices run from $37,120 (2021) to $61,647 (2026), based on 738 live listings.

How much is a 2026 BMW M440I?

A used 2026 BMW M440I typically lists for $61,647, with most asking prices between $54,502 and $71,512. Average odometer reading is 9,582 miles.

What's the cheapest year of the BMW M440I worth looking at?

The 2021 model year is the least expensive quotable year at a typical $37,120 — but compare its mileage (54,596 miles on average) and per-year table above before deciding; a newer year at a small premium often carries far fewer miles.

How fast does the BMW M440I depreciate?

Across adjacent model years currently on the market, the M440I steps down a median 9.8% per model year of age — e.g. moving one year older typically saves about that share of the price.

How much does the trim change a used M440I's price?

A lot: over the last 4 model years, the cheapest common trim (GRAN COUPE) typically lists for $52,810 while the priciest (CONVERTIBLE) runs $57,611 — a $4,801 spread within the same nameplate. The most common trim on the used market is the XDRIVE (42.9% of trim-labeled listings) at a typical $56,170.

How much is a used 2024 BMW M440I?

A used 2024 BMW M440I typically lists for $51,332, with most asking prices between $44,847 and $58,016; average odometer is 28,755 miles (186 for sale).

About this data: prices, ranges and mileage are national aggregates of 738 live VehiSales listings (November 2026), refreshed daily; model years with fewer than 20 live cars are not quoted. Fuel economy: U.S. EPA/DOE. Safety: NHTSA NCAP. How to cite: “VehiSales Research, Used BMW M440I Prices by Year” with a link to https://vehisales.com/research/prices/bmw/m440i.

See also: BMW M440I hub — live listings & specs · BMW M440I MPG by year · All model price pages · Best used cars by budget.

© 2026 VehiSales · Data from live US vehicle listings · Methodology · Editorial policy · About · Privacy Policy · Cookie settings / Do not sell or share · Press: cite as “VehiSales Used Car Price Index” with a link to this page.